How to get a catering quote in Brooklyn NY that covers staffing and rentals

Originally Posted On: https://www.bonsoircaterers.com/2026/10/14/how-to-get-a-catering-quote-in-brooklyn-ny-that-covers-staffing-and-rentals/

What You’ll Need Before You Ask a Brooklyn Caterer for a Quote

Getting a solid catering quote in Brooklyn, NY takes about 45 to 60 minutes of prep and one 20-minute call. Gather this first and you’ll skip three rounds of back-and-forth emails.

• Rough guest count. A range works (say, 110 to 130). Caterers price in tiers, so a number within 10 beats a guess.

• Event date and a backup date. Saturdays in June, September, and October book out fast around Brooklyn.

• Budget range, per person and total. Know what you can spend on food, bar, staffing, and rentals combined.

• Venue name, address, and contract. Look for the catering clause, any approved-caterer list, and the kitchen setup. Historic spots like the Prospect Park Boathouse or Queens County Farm Museum often have strict load-in rules.

• Load-in details. Is there an elevator? Stairs? A loading zone or street parking only? This changes how many staff you’ll need.

• Dietary list. Count the vegetarian, vegan, gluten-free, and allergy guests. Even a rough tally helps.

• Service style in mind. Plated dinner, buffet, self-service, or BBQ. Pick a lead choice and a backup.

• Bar preference. Full open bar, beer and wine only, signature cocktails, or a custom setup.

• A short list of 2 to 3 caterers. Include one chain restaurant option if you want a price check.

• Notes app or spreadsheet. You’ll want to compare quotes line by line, not by the bottom-line total.

Skills: Basic budgeting and the nerve to ask, “Is that included?” That’s it.

Time needed: About an hour to prep, 20 minutes per caterer call — a day or two for written quotes to come back.

A catering quote that skips staffing and rentals isn’t a quote. It’s a teaser. Plenty of Brooklyn couples find that out three weeks before the wedding, when a $95-a-head estimate quietly turns into $140 once servers, chairs, linens, and a delivery fee show up on the final invoice.

Catering in Brooklyn, NY comes with its own quirks.

Your venue might be a 1905 boathouse in Prospect Park or a brick-walled loft where the freight elevator runs on its own schedule. Kitchen access is tight. Load-in windows are short. Street parking? Forget it. Every one of those details changes what a caterer has to bring, and what they’ll charge for it.

Here’s what 25 years of off-premises work teaches you: the price on page one rarely tells the real story. Food travels well, or it doesn’t. Staff shows up in the right numbers, or they don’t. And the couples who end up happy are the ones who asked the right questions before they signed anything.

So how do you get a number you can actually trust? Start with what a good caterer needs from you, then push for every line item in writing. It’s easier than it sounds, and it’ll save you real money.

What You’ll Get Done and What to Have Ready Before You Call a Brooklyn Caterer

A couple in Park Slope books the Prospect Park Boathouse, calls three caterers on a Tuesday night — gets three quotes that can’t be compared. One leaves out staff. One skips rentals. Nobody’s wrong. They just weren’t asked the same questions. Here’s how to fix that: by the end of this guide, you’ll have one apples-to-apples quote for catering that covers food, bar, staffing, and rentals.

The Five Numbers Every Caterer Asks For First

Have these ready. Fast.

1. Guest count: a firm range, like 120 to 135.

2. Budget: a per-person figure, not a vague total.

3. Service hours: cocktail hour through last call.

4. Bar headcount: how many guests will actually drink.

5. Courses: buffet stations, plated dinner, or finger-food reception.

Skip one and the quote is a guess.

Documents and Details to Pull Together (Venue Contract, Guest Count, Dietary List)

Pull your venue contract first. Brooklyn’s historic spaces often limit kitchen access, load-in times, and outside vendors (some require a certificate of insurance, too). Next, build your dietary list: vegetarian, vegan, gluten-free, and allergies, with names where you can.

• Signed venue contract and floor plan

• Load-in window and elevator details

• Rental list, if the venue supplies nothing

• Dietary and allergy tally

Got all that? Then you’re ready to call.

Step 1: Lock Your Guest Count, Date, and Budget Range

No caterer can price an event without three numbers. Guest count, date, and budget. Skip one and the quote you get back is a guess.

Start with the headcount. Pull your list together and count the people who’ll actually show up, not everyone you invited. In Brooklyn, expect roughly 80 to 85 percent of invited guests to attend a weekend wedding. A 120-person invite list usually means about 100 plates, and that gap moves the price of food, staffing, and rentals all at once.

Next, pin the date. Saturdays in June, September, and October fill up first, and peak-season pricing is real. Friday evenings and Sunday brunch receptions (a mimosa-and-buffet setup works well) often cost less. Flexibility here saves money.

Then set a budget range, not a single figure. Give a floor and a ceiling. Here’s what to settle before you call Brooklyn caterers:

• Guest count: a firm number plus a 10 percent buffer

• Date: your first choice and one backup

• Budget: a per-person range covering food, bar, staff, and rentals

• Venue: name and any in-house rules for outside caterers

Got those four? Good. You’re ready to ask for a real quote.

Step 2: Check Your Venue’s Catering Rules, Kitchen Access, and Load-In Limits

Historic and Scenic Venues: Why Landmark Spaces Change the Quote

Ever wonder why two weddings with the same guest count get wildly different catering quotes? The venue. Landmark spaces come with rules that a standard banquet hall never has.

Take the Prospect Park Boathouse, built in 1905 and a designated landmark. Or the Queens County Farm Museum, dating to 1697. Neither was built with a commercial kitchen in mind. So the crew often cooks off-site or sets up a tented prep area, and that costs money.

Here’s what most couples miss: every limit on the venue side shows up as a line item on yours. Ask the venue these questions before you request pricing:

• Is there a working kitchen, or only a warming space?

• Where can the truck park, and for how long?

• Are there stairs or an elevator for trays, rentals, and bar gear?

• What’s the load-in window, and what’s the overtime rate?

• Do you require an approved caterer list or proof of insurance?

A seasoned Brooklyn caterer will have worked most of these rooms already. That experience matters. A long carry from the curb means extra staff, and no kitchen means extra rentals. Hand those answers over upfront, and your quote covers staffing and rentals the first time.

Step 3: Pick Your Service Style and Menu Direction (Full-Service, Buffet, Self-Service, BBQ)

Small Party Catering on a Budget vs. a 150-Guest Wedding Menu

Staffing can eat up 20 to 30 percent of a wedding catering bill. Most couples never see that coming. Pick the wrong service style and your quote swings by thousands.

Start with headcount. Then match the style to it.

• Under 50 guests, tight budget: Go self-service. Think trays of roast chicken, a deli-style sandwich spread, or a Low & Slow BBQ buffet. Skip the plated dinner. You’ll save on servers and rentals.

• 150 guests, historic venue: Go full-service. Plated courses or stations need a real crew, plus linens, china, and glassware. Ask the caterer to itemize all of it.

Here’s what most people miss: a buffet isn’t automatically cheap. At 150 people, you still need attendants, chafers, and extra tables. Realistically, a good buffet lands between the two extremes.

A seasoned Brooklyn catering company will quote each style side by side, so you can compare the real numbers. Ask for that. And ask what’s included in each version, because a lunch-style drop-off and a seated dinner aren’t the same job.

Budget tight? Cut courses, not staff.

Step 4: Decide on Bar Packages and Get Them in the Same Quote

Open bars aren’t automatically the safe choice. Plenty of Brooklyn couples overspend on top-shelf liquor that guests barely touch, then wonder why the bar line ate $4,000 of the catering budget.

So price it properly. Ask any NYC caterer to put the bar on the same quote as the menu, staffing, and rentals. Separate bar bids hide costs (glassware, ice, bartenders), and you’ll only spot them after you’ve signed.

Here are the four package types worth comparing:

• Premium Open Bar: top-shelf spirits, three beers, one white, one red, one sparkling, plus mixers and juices.

• Beer & Wine Only: the same beer and wine picks, no liquor. Often the smartest cut for a 100-guest crowd.

• Signature Cocktail: one or two classic or custom drinks, which keeps the menu tight and the mood personal.

• Custom Bar: built to your specs.

Pricing depends on selection, guest count, and service hours. Tell the caterer your venue (a Prospect Park Boathouse reception runs differently than a rooftop loft) and ask who supplies bartenders, glassware, and rentals. Get every line itemized.

Step 5: Ask for Staffing and Rental Line Items Spelled Out

A couple booked the Prospect Park Boathouse for 120 guests. The quote said, “service staff included.” On the night, four servers showed up. Nobody had asked how many were needed, and the cocktail hour fell apart. Don’t let a vague line sink your quote.

Ask for every cost broken out.

A food catering Brooklyn quote should list people and gear separately, not bundle them into one number.

Staffing Ratios, Overtime, and Gratuity Questions

Start with ratios. A plated dinner usually needs one server per 15 to 20 guests, while a buffet can run closer to one per 30. Then ask:

• How many bartenders, captains, and kitchen hands are on the quote?

• What’s the hourly overtime rate once the event runs past the contracted end time?

• Is gratuity or a service charge already included, and who actually receives it?

Brooklyn venues often enforce strict load-out times. Overtime adds up fast.

Linens, Chairs, Tableware, and Who Handles Delivery and Pickup

Rentals are where surprise fees hide. Get each item priced per piece: linens, chairs, plates, flatware, glassware, and serving trays. Confirm the count matches your guest list plus a small buffer.

Then pin down logistics. Who delivers, and when? Who picks up the next morning? Walk-up apartments and landmark buildings without a freight elevator can mean extra labor charges. Ask about those before signing, not after.

Step 6: Compare Brooklyn Caterers Side by Side, Including Chain Restaurant Catering

Quotes only mean something when they’re lined up in the same format. Build a simple sheet with one row per caterer and the same columns for everyone.

What to Put in Your Comparison Sheet

• Per-person food price for the same menu style, whether buffet or plated

• Staffing: servers, bartenders, and setup crew, with hourly rates and minimums

• Rentals: linens, chairs, glassware, and who handles pickup

• Bar package: open bar, beer and wine only, or signature cocktails

• Fees: delivery, service charge, gratuity, and tax

Where Chain Restaurant Catering Fits

Chipotle, Chick-fil-A, and Olive Garden all sell party trays, and the prices look cheap. For a 50-person office lunch or a Super Bowl party, that works fine. For a wedding at the Prospect Park Boathouse? Not so much.

Trays arrive in foil.

No servers, no bar, no rentals, no one to reheat anything. Add those costs back in, and the gap shrinks fast.

If barbecue is on your list, ask for a Brooklyn BBQ catering quote using the same guest count and service hours, then drop it into the sheet. Compare the totals, not the headline price per head.

Common Mistakes That Blow Up a Catering Quote (and How to Fix Them)

Why does one Brooklyn couple’s catering quote land at $14,000 while another’s for the same guest count hits $22,000? Usually it’s what got left out of the first request, not the food.

Here’s what trips people up most. Fix each one before you hit send.

• Quoting food only. Ask for staffing, rentals, and bar service as separate line items. A cheap per-head menu price means nothing if servers and linens show up later as add-ons.

• Guessing the headcount. Give a firm range, like 90 to 100 guests. Padding by 20 people can add thousands.

• Skipping venue rules. Historic spots, like the Prospect Park Boathouse, have kitchen and load-in limits. Tell the caterer up front.

• Ignoring bar math. Premium open bar, beer and wine only, and signature cocktail packages price very differently by service hour.

• Comparing unlike menus. A buffet and a plated dinner aren’t the same job. Compare quotes on the same format.

But here’s the thing. Most of these mistakes come from rushing.

Send every caterer the same written brief. Then ask each one to itemize. Apples to apples, no surprises.

Next Steps: How to Check That Your Catering Quote Is Complete Before You Sign

Roughly 1 in 3 couples hit a surprise charge after signing — it’s almost always staffing or rentals. Brooklyn couples feel it most, since historic venues often arrive with bare kitchens and strict load-in rules.

So audit the paper before you pay a deposit. Fast.

Run This Checklist Line by Line

1. Staff count and hours. Bartenders, servers, captain, and setup crew should be listed, with overtime rates spelled out.

2. Rentals. Confirm who supplies linens, glassware, chafers, and trays, and who picks them up.

3. Bar package. Check the tier (beer and wine, signature cocktail, or open bar), plus mixers, juices, and ice.

4. Menu per guest. Cocktail hour, buffet or plated dinner, and a vegetarian count.

5. Venue fees. Ask about elevator use, parking, and any cleanup charges.

Ask These Before You Sign

Does the price include tax — service charge? What happens if your guest count drops by 20 people? Who is on-site the night of the wedding?

Here’s what most people miss: a cheap-looking quote with rentals left out is rarely cheaper. Get the final number in writing, then compare it against a second caterer’s quote, line for line.

How-To FAQ

How far ahead should I ask for a catering quote in Brooklyn, NY?

Start 9 to 12 months out for a Saturday wedding at a historic or scenic venue. Peak dates in May, June, September — October fill fast. For a small party or a Friday or Sunday event, 8 to 12 weeks usually works. Quotes themselves come back quickly, often within 2 to 3 business days once you’ve given a firm guest count and venue.

What should a complete catering quote include?

A complete quote lists food, bar, staffing, and rentals as separate line items. Don’t accept a single per-person number with no breakdown. Check for these:

• Food and menu: price per guest, plus any extra charge for vegetarian, vegan, or allergy meals

• Staffing: number of servers and bartenders, hours, overtime rate, and gratuity

• Rentals: linens, chairs, tableware, glassware, and delivery and pickup fees

• Bar: package type, service time, mixers, ice, and cups

• Taxes and fees: NYC sales tax and any service charge

What’s the cheapest food to cater for a small party?

Pasta, chicken, and self-service buffet spreads cost the least per guest. Labor is where you save most, so a self-service setup beats a plated dinner every time. For a 50-guest party on a budget, skip the formal staffing and pick a drop-off menu. Fast food trays from chain restaurants look cheap, but they often leave out serving staff, chafing setups, and bar service, so the gap shrinks once you add those back.

What if my venue won’t let outside caterers use the kitchen?

Ask the venue for its written catering rules before you request a quote. Many Brooklyn and Manhattan venues limit kitchen access, elevator times, or load-in windows. Tell the caterer up front. A caterer who works off-premises daily can plan around a small prep area with warming equipment, and that planning saves you from surprise labor charges on the day.

Can one caterer handle the bar, staffing, and rentals so I’m not chasing three vendors?

Yes, and it’s usually the easier route. Some full-service caterers, including Bon Soir Caterers in Brooklyn, offer bar packages, staffing, rental coordination, and vendor referrals under one quote. Ask whether rentals are billed at cost or marked up. Either way, one invoice makes it simple to compare against other bids.

How do I compare a quote from a chain restaurant with one from a local caterer?

Compare total cost for the same guest count, with the same services included. Chain catering often covers food only. Add what you’d still need to pay for: servers, setup, plates, linens, and cleanup. Then line it up against the caterer’s all-in number. If the local quote is within 15 to 20 percent, the extra service is usually worth it for a wedding.

A good quote isn’t a mystery. It’s a document, and it either lists everything or it doesn’t.

Couples planning a Brooklyn wedding who do the groundwork first get cleaner numbers. They know the guest count, the date, and a budget range before the first call. They’ve also read the venue’s rules on kitchen access and load-in, which matters at landmark spaces where a caterer can’t just wheel a cart through the front door. Then comes the part most people skip: staffing hours, overtime, linens, chairs, and delivery all appear as separate lines, not buried in a flat per-head price. Bar service belongs in that same document.

Once two or three quotes sit side by side, the gaps show up fast. A cheap total with no rentals listed isn’t cheap. It’s unfinished.

Here’s the next step. Pull together your venue contract, dietary list, and five core numbers, then call Bon Soir Caterers at 718.763.9420 and ask for a quote that itemizes catering, staffing, rentals, and bar packages together. Check every line before you sign anything.

Bon Soir Caterers
1421 E 63rd St., Brooklyn, NY 11234
(718) 763-9420
bonsoircaterers.com
View Google Business Profile
Follow us: Facebook · Instagram · Pinterest